xt73bk16mf8w_57 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/mets.xml https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/51w14.dao.xml unknown 35 Cubic Feet 77 boxes archival material 51w14 English University of Kentucky Copyright has not been assigned to the University of Kentucky.  Contact the Special Collections Research Center for information regarding rights and use of this collection. Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company and Lexington and Eastern Railway Company records Railroads -- Appalachian Region -- History. Railroads -- Kentucky -- History. [29] Monroe Ballard vs. L&E, Fayette Justice Court text [29] Monroe Ballard vs. L&E, Fayette Justice Court 2016 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/51w14/Box_7/Folder_4/63985.pdf section false xt73bk16mf8w_57 xt73bk16mf8w H‘ ., _ ‘ 4 W;. % .,.. ‘ g ‘_ > \ "V :' ,.~’;
- ‘. ‘ December 31, 1915. .
W. A. Moﬁowéil, Esq., , 4 _-
‘ Manager, L & E ﬁy.Co., _ - I ’
Lexington,Ky. ' ' 1
Dear Sir:— _
An$wering your favor of the 24th instant, relative to the
ease of Monroe Ballard v. the L & E Ry.Co. for time due, I have to
say that this case was tried this morning in 'Squire Oldham's Court .
and éismirsoﬁ without prejuﬂiaa.
. Yours ﬁrmly, '
‘ SEW/A .'
- ‘ Counsel. .' _
’ g

 . Y .. ' ‘ If ' .‘, ,_ ,,)
» ' .. ' r _ . _‘ .r' or ' J ' -- ’4?“
..V ./ . 1 ’,.-V ./> {V ._ _’., / {qu _ b; w / : 7’ ’4‘/’,’ 7 > ‘2 0,»; , 1%;
. <;)£3 . , f; Véﬁ’ ’7! ‘826§) 2/4/ yi/fﬁ
] c /,«/,r 7 4 ; r X, y .1" ,&/ x, , T, ;/ X 2 ;/ // ,’,r /,-// ,’
lira/z/zy/ﬂ/zx m/ ('1:/5/ M/zo _m MW}! Wag/40%
C n ’ 1‘ Am, A. ‘ if .‘ ‘ .‘— :V‘ _ \V V , 9 . . ‘..‘. ‘.‘vrv>",:“,-‘7-'!:?‘." J an v-xuwm
. K I}; ;/// x ""’Ayv/Q/‘i/ // m, 1 5,1”, ‘, »'5 9., ‘
’ ///fM/(// ﬂu},
,. .“L. ' " .-f .1 .. z
.,//(ﬂl(/(yﬂ'/; ;;‘ cVVE311 . H
Superintendent Bradshaw replied:

"Monroe Ballard the has sued Co. is not
employed on L.C.& L. He have no foreman named Jim Southern.
Smith says no such foreman in Construction Department."

The Paymester wired:
" N0 foreman named Jim Southern"
The Headmaster of Construction wired:
"Jim Southern Exg No.2 does not work under me."

Monroe Ballard Was in my office the day of the 18th,
asking for his time and furnished the information that he had worked
in November for Jim Southern, Extra Gang 2, at Covington. He was
told that we would request the Paymasaer to send his time to

‘ Lexington, as it is not the order of things in making payment by
the Paymester to do so unless the party is known personally by the
Peymaster, or is properly identified.

Furthermore, it is a requirement and a fact generally known
to employee as to then payments are to be made at the various points
and that it is necessary that each individual be with the gang to
draw such money, the foreman making the identification. In cases

L L , L V» ' - -- V - . A. ._-‘ .
Where the indiVJdual does not meet the pay car for such yeyment the
next step would be to have the Deymaster send a ticket to a point

 l

" S. H. W. 2.
as might be designated by the omploye, the oayment being nude
through an agent and then only on identification.

The above may not be pertinent to the case in question
but it is by way of explanation of Yhﬂt B llord should have done
to secure the amount claimed from the Company. If Ballard was
aware of the facts above stated, and it is my Opinion that he mas,
esneciellr so if it can be shown that he he; bee; working for
the Company for any length of time, could we not claim exemption
under the law of equity, that of the Golden Rule?

The facts as we have been able to secure them, controvert
all claims made by Ballard in his conVersation prior to service of the
garnishee.

I do not beliebe Ballard can ohom refusal to pay on the gart
of this Comvaiy as is required according to all rules and laws of
buxiness but can perhaps show delayed payment. We stand ready
to produce any amount due,ri5htfully belongin; JO him, provided he
can furnish the exact location 0' his eervices. It was not a

' case for the court but oneﬁor Ballard's common sense. If it is
desired we will produce our file in court on any day set by you
as the facts can be furnished by us as well as the Paymester, the
Superintendents at Louisvil e and Paris, and the Roedmester of
Construcgion at Covington, there being nositive information from
each of them that Jim Southern was not a foreman under them.

Yodrs truly,
I’. \f/* \5 ﬁg’liY?)
v V ,/ Managers“ ,§>‘ //
75’ , _\ \X - '
B .
\——/ .
j/

 ‘i " ‘ . ' . Docombei £6,I1915.
’ ~ ' W, A. McDowell, Isq., I ~
manager; T a». T: 337.00.,
V Lexington,Ky. V  
Dear Sir:- . _
Reforring again ﬁo the suit in Squire Gﬁdham's
Court of Honroe Ballard v. Iouicvillo & Hashville H.?.Co.,' .
I have found since dictating my last 19 tor to you regarding
this case that while the Suit is only against the Louisvillo &
Haohville T.R. Co., that no effort was mono to oummon the true; »
ﬁefohdant by delivering or offering to ﬁolivor the sum ons upon
any agent of said Louiovj lo & Haohvillo 3.3.Co., but the sum-
mons, as appears from your own lctﬁoi of recent date and gzio
Cholosures thorvwith and also from the memorandum dockeéghimr
servca ’ .
v i1§élf,wasAonly upon Arthur Cary as ?resioent of the hexington &
Eastern Railway Company. Upon Guo consiﬁeration of the matter, .
I fool sure that such manner of service was wholly insufficient
to bring the Louisville & Koshvillo Railroad Company before the
Court in this suit and the suit/being only broughﬁ expressly
against the Louisville & Nashville Railroad Company. of course,
tho Loxington & Eastern Railway Company ané its Piosiﬁeht or é‘
other officials can have no proﬁor place in the litigation
or in the defense thereof. In View of these facto/which have
1 come to my knoWlodgc more clearly since I wrote you, I have .
E reinforcea our motion to set asiﬂo the default juagment and to hav
F a now trial granted by Showing to the Court that the summons in
1 . the first inotohco was not properly served and that tho officer‘s
return ﬁhoroon should be quashed. If a new trial is not granfed

 . . . ‘,‘és
‘ E
o- 2.
'27. A. MOD.#2. 12/26/15.
and the plaintiff ineiots on having the benefit of the default
juégment rendered by the Court, I think there would be good
grounﬁs for enjoining the enforcement of the juﬂgment. However,
the amount involvoﬁ is so small that such expensive proceedings
as an injunction woulo involve would barely be justified to '
’ defeat the enforoentnt of this judgment. I am hopeful, hoﬁever,
that upon a full and proper presentation of the matter that
Squire Qldham will promptly not asiﬁe the default judgment
‘ lately rendered and grant the éofendant a new trial — that is
will require the plaintiff to take a fresh hold and start
. over again by having the Summons for the Zouisville & Hashville
serveﬁ on some local agent of the Company. '
. ' Very truly yours,
SEW/A '
Counsel.
\h_ .
x 9 ‘

 ,,, (77//7/// ”HM / /ﬂ///’/’// ; //// /_/’/// ‘/ /’//%//////,
' / /.‘ , I , / /
.A W ~//////./////////////w/ (ﬁg/WWW %.
(%-n%{ga//t//L% t/‘m” ,
”Ea/ﬂ I ' / / I '
_ ’ I" f/j”////-/I/AV/A/rl/l/n/fv/LJ
. , / ,
December 24, 1913.

2?. A. Hcﬁowoll, Esq.,
Ianagor, L & R Ry.CO.,
EouisVille,Ky.
Boar Sir:-

Your letter of ﬁne mbnr 22nd, encloaing summons in the
0&36 of Honroe Ballard v. Icuisville & Narhvi?1e R 3 Co., rhachod
my office yesterday, the 35rd instant, after I hgd 16ft on the
mmrning C & D for iouixvi?10. CﬁlSOthhtlj, ? ﬂiﬁ not 500 it
in the mail which oumc in the first morning ﬁciivnry of ﬁuesday,
thick I found on my desk and examined befmro taking ﬁhe train.
I first say your letter ani thv miclnnnre $unsday night about
9 O’clock on my return from Iouievillo. ‘

From the SUM40£S (ané much tho enc?asrrw uppvura to be)
it appears that thr trial of the case was set by Squirn ilﬂham
for 10 o'clach f.ﬁ., Tuesday, 300 mbcr 25rd. Thjs summons was
issued on theiBth instant uné nervcd at 9:25 é.3. on the sane
Gate. 0f coursn, under the circumctamcoa, I have had no op—
pcrbunity whatever oithmr $0 prnparc for trial or to make any
defense ﬁg who plaintiff’s 0131 . T will tak< the mattnr up
with Squire Glaham, hOWmvor, and $00 if Eha ﬁcfault judgment
ronﬁerea in my absence may not be Hﬁt amide anﬁ the ease tried
out on iba merita. I call HCSCZtiQn here, however, to the fact
ﬁhaﬁ thu Rupﬁrintcnﬁont of the Knntucky Division does not state

 K ,/ ﬂ , j / / /
/‘ ' / K ‘ / / / '
/ ' ’ / ’ I / ‘ / I / I
r, /./////7’ /// ////// / m2 //// . /// // my //////////,
‘. / /" ,' / / _/
_ . _A //1/ ///_f//’////’/////’/// g ' (an ‘9? .
{gfzwuw/ ./[/ W042 W7 ; y
(«3/ ‘//=' /
m x / v ,. '
\ ram” //
' v ’ ' 1' V ’l
, / I
(v? 5‘, k 1].!
ti o T 0—4013. $.31. 12/24/3.59
in so many words that the Company anvs ”allard nuthing or that
Ballard has no valid claim against the Company, but Cirply
‘.s n . r , r n .2 .1 . .. “.ﬁ‘ - ‘ w, - . ...,
that he has no record or Uhls name aha is unaolo to locate
an amount in Usllard’s fever." You, if, on a trial, Ballard
hi self csmos in and testifies to his a? cgnd wnpl yacht and
tho rnndition of services by him sci the resulting mﬁdohtednoss
of the Railroad Company, how are we going to meet this! If
the Superinton3ont is pr parrd to deny fletiy that Ballard was
- ever employed or, if Foreman 9vuthorn,in charge of 7xtra Gang
Ho. 2 at Covingtvn, will contradiﬁt Va‘larﬁ’s ﬁrstiwony in sup-
port of his claim, then We night stand some chance of defeating
the
it, but, without the testimony either ofAﬂupcrintondont ’
or of Far man Southern, I am afraid we will be worsted on a
trial.
If I succeed in having the default judgment sot aside,
I will try to have the care a signed for trial on some convenient
II’I‘f‘fx ‘n J" n ‘1’!!‘\"(‘ J's-Vt - 7> ‘3 n7 7x7 3’: m '1 " 'l‘\{‘)""+‘ v‘r» 3" T
\lL»v“a’ 1,1; on», ]L(.'(J«.'. .‘.Li 1.11.0, p- O')<_.L 3,3,)! 0.. ”07710 wary “Mike: A]. ( .‘.‘Lu ~17.
reply to this letter, you might indicate what we may expect
i: the way of cviﬁcnca and also indicrto what day next week
would probably be tho most convenient for trial.
Very truly yours ,
(F‘vvv;/A
»_-'i, a; 1‘.
Counsel.

 .‘ :--/W/l/7/// m”) (( 'K/J/W/W — , //1/ ”WV ////%////7,
I Q / I K / / .7 / / /’
. ‘ JK/(ww'ﬂ/ / 7/271
‘ /////7// // /’ / . / /
lf/ﬂrmzjyﬂ'z. ;—_,I //.I)K/////I//’//Ip iyl
,4 /"
,. .1'.“ ._, 5;. ;b/oﬁ 02 3 4’3
.1. .... y .,i I _' ; M9 II;_. ’_.”.I ..:;.
'4 - 3.. I.; . , ;. _ __. _, ; /I%’zi-I ' ‘,- 2. ‘ i
/ , ~ I/I/IV I]: I 0 ,
;/ \F “‘ '

 5: /’3"' ‘ 1 l“ '7 ’ ,,, . ,- - . . (2‘74" '7 . , ,.
, {,,“17€<’LL/1-i,JUSTICI; Oi“ HHS .'r‘lui’Lii‘l ,,,,,,,,,1...Z,a,,................DISI‘HIH
$3110'ConlmnnwvuliIi «if l{(‘liﬁiil’ii}'. 1
To the Sheriff or any Constable of Fayette County;
J ’7 i \ )7 '
. , ’ ,. ,4 . , 3 . .
You are commanded to summon“”’(QZiL/t’,»7/(44 ﬂgtKﬂL/
/, ,/ " x ,1», '7
i
to answer on the ﬁrst day of the tuttim in this court. or in the Court of an}:
Justice of the Peace in said County to which this summons may he [nun-nod. at the ﬁrst term thereof
"71 ' . /
. . , ,/ ' , , , / .5 “ , / , /
beginning . ._.g;._~u:i.ﬁ..+f_..---::....Z /L1-,//./.*(Z/-// ‘5/1’Z‘K ._
/ / ,,
7 i , /,
. r A - . ‘- . , 1 . ,
I: /'\()
amounting to $ /../(‘ .. ....,.._,.................\\'hich
,1 I . i / , 7V
tuni...,;.__.__,_,,__..._..has been ﬁled in my oihco, and wzn n.____,1;f,__ ____..........._that upon...,,,z_.._ 2 faihn’e to answer the
/ ¢ / " /
(///é/({will be taken for confessed 01//\\111 he proceeded against for contempt.
“ . , ,‘,/4“ 2L/ . . V
(IIVQH under my hand as I.Iustice of the Penna, DlSil‘M‘i’. Fayette (..ounty
. ,1«(/'/( I . U . 7
. V / \3 . . 7 - (I 4 .
this /3 day 0t 1.14%: Lila)"

 ,' _ xv“: ' , - 3.;
, -_,. ‘ a ‘.
. , \~ ‘ ‘ ' I k
\ U) . Lu : .: - ,
y/ﬂku.’ I ‘1 " _. , ‘ (Z) 3 £5 5 5, (‘7'.
~ 1 : ': E [L
‘ . 2 ' b 2 . - , .
F‘IamilﬁC D: 1 . - ~
to g < : : E
Z . m 5 g '
" ‘ :_: : 8% E E F
, eUMMONe : g < g L
3 3' o Z i
Lu 3 t‘ S S 3
I 5 3 3 3
+— : E : 5
Deiendant O 5 > g S f
: LL ' D: 3
> z —- 0 +— .
CL - P— - :
o i 0 LL g e
O i Z i u. j
.. .. “J 5 Q - : ;
. Altorney 03: <2: 1 _. E
»— 3 . 5 93 §
< 5 _= E . S
, C) : : ;
(D ; —. ' : g
E 3 3 3 3 :
0: E 3 : 3 E
“J 2 5 3 9 ?
2 E : z : 5
_J E E E E
UJ : : : ;
D E 3 E 3
> 5 2 5
m E 2 : 1.
D 5 : 5 E
UJ : : : :
’— 2 3 E 3
D . .‘ : :
O ' 3 E E
Lu , : : '
. X : 3 g :
4- . LE! 3 : : :
o‘ 5 i
t- : : :

 ‘ .
‘.
FAY“ WE? JU.‘ ‘TIC'VS COUR T.

licmfoc 3:4"? are, Plaintiff.

V. 7.“??? ’ “T“: ‘1‘-IV”.
Trntim’illc 8: ”V :: Taffy-9.x“: Co., Defendemt.

.«.»«.-—--_()(j;q_——~—_....

L’E'." (1013‘:163.7%;, "You? "‘.‘."”‘t.‘_“C «"~ 7"::~'~"=‘r‘.‘."7""e "‘is‘u‘ﬂifoad Cord-
EF-ili’YJf‘. t‘:‘i”"i‘i1""1'7:‘77 93":‘1"<‘I"ﬁ‘ (9173-7 To." j’mr’olwra of making“ the pres-
‘YTL' .‘YiQ‘bjO? ‘.'“:Tfi‘Y’TYI: it" i).§":’_f:"€..'-"f;‘m‘ .<_'.. S. Qprfrznﬁayit to thlS
not: 1‘1, (wow .5 7 :‘,-was that (Hg-1.‘“: 1'2" er“:- szsrir’ic tho (iofmxlt
"M L; exw':u.-’-7_\.12 ‘ "1 the vii-:':. f; EasilivaYc
“,.'-7:71'i1fned Sirel'gﬂii‘ﬂff or. ’Tiéz‘sﬁeg', T'cca-‘TCJ-er £75, 791.". 5:326: to .',:razit
‘3”; the G<~fL-:’:z§.z~:.-.t hex-(3‘12? 2 711;“: trio": of this (action.

ficccz‘virtg‘ its :':ppvcrsuic" i1: tceTrim" the present mo-
tion am} for all “91127302103 except to main." the ‘1‘):i‘r'erwt notion, I
"the ~ictfz‘rnr‘ir.?:'?":, r 'ﬁ'iif‘: “ TiniJLI'cm CI’;3"1_.T_):J.11;;7, now
come and states that :2.: .:rp‘cczai'c from the etctr‘wnt {2115: pro-
oe ».‘: it": this; case-7:. ‘Jhe swiqrz has been "institute-6i. Le..t'_-‘:ainct the
T:o‘:1i:t7‘.rii1c 5: Fiaf“‘.’:':‘rilio 7:27, rum? Twin-.233] :13 offer/Rant; but that

' :::: :‘7)};3v“7::.2.*s3 from tho 260511211 on ’:?‘u‘ 5321:1133“ 5" if”.‘~“.-LI’“"“. heroin, said

f“:.i?33tf‘1.")“‘:.'53 was: not in :35:-ct nerveﬂ. upon the ' <.\:1.:i.:'rvi.|3o E: iiaehvi] lo
3331:351'08ﬂ Cox'ipeny or any agent of seia Company, "out, on tho
contrar -, woo actually serWrG on the Lexington 3: Earthen; Rail-
way Company by delivering: to ﬁrthur Cary, Presir‘wnt of $9.161
Lexington c" Factory) i‘iailway Company, a copy of said summons.

Defendant states that the do? ivory of ezazid BRITNO‘IES
to the President of the ﬂexington 8L: Eastern Railway Campsmy w:

 .
‘ -
'0
“_p__
'L:~"=:‘_'r'r‘:{‘::'_‘i':i5:714; 730 "2:131:14; "123:1; 63:11:“::3'11'.'.:;:r2t, 71:11:11}11'i3'_l_:1 5; I!a521vi?‘.1 (3
Yrs.“ 3131;“: Twit-:1: , ‘:Jeéréfzr-“e ‘:3'1-7; 31:13.21": 12.11. 1:110 prosynﬁ; ;au‘it for tithe
::.-:::'1::"s1-. phat; :'::22723 5:3”011‘1‘173 (.':;:fy is; 310‘: :m c-z‘ficizsl or 8507113 of the
T:r:‘;‘-1:‘3:s'-_:v 730 :’: ':L'::=-':':1"3'2‘Fc “2 115711-3213: ‘1)11’2. 11:: .:..7:>crv'c—srﬁatm‘:,
11:51:: 01".“..37' "231+; 3.12:1. 11:7. via 1*" :.': whiff 11‘-:'::‘1117‘111‘9 ":'i’f'iunr :31” ”511.: 7:03:-
"1». :‘::w 711:1: 1.3:. r1». 72151.11: 1.1:! if 1::1':‘::;.':‘;;~'1 '7"r:’2’c:ré:"m-‘: s:“:;::.*1::::-.= 1:11:14; :31: was
it“: ‘:t.$'v:7.::--"::’ 32': 27:21: 3"",31 5::: 1:1‘1171-“131137' Of. 3.3112“: ‘:.—11 -2:--;_ 811.131.1741 «or
1101: was it 2:161: divirgrx‘. thcrcof
111—:2Cram}: ;’ 1.31““ '1tz-T43Ata:1';t'ff. :'::"73: :1" 5:212: 3.‘~.:1r3‘?.tfr_zr1 {‘2 1‘“ t3)“ juﬂjKﬂ‘b
? rum :1"; 3,11-1..1»:11‘111-7- 5'31 3:171. 7'3, 5::-:1 “"7134: _:'-::1 ::z1.j:‘,‘: 5:411:11, 51.17531: 2210
":‘-"“1651???fo 912' :'::“if‘x 513:”: _:3- E" , 1":31351‘13'“? ;" if“)? 3:31? 71:71::111545511': 8:
'Eff.‘:'_"3<.“_r“~‘: '13:::?_’r'.‘..'1‘:;7 7"”:12113 EVEN" "15;: i1: ’3131',3'f; }::,j;;-:1a-.1j.1735; «I‘./33¢ 3&1
3:214:15”: ‘1'; 21:25:1303321 T511112???) 7<7T":-1‘::z:,.7 :31“ E’Cyet‘bn 0011111537 1m" 8180
7'11“ 5'23!“ ‘.‘W'T'TY": #7")?! :2'7.1,r:1~r)-2f 1'3"}? ‘2‘:1st".’I;'-_ztis“:2‘z (1.21:3 ;31‘1313'10‘12'351311
:1 tuft?- writ-1 I7: 7:5“,1‘}?’:‘:"t it: 0"? that thr- aummcns 11‘: this
fizz-"'1: 111‘: 17‘“:"*‘,:r:-r":';7 3:- »~,—1:15;: 11:27 the: "i=1711ra‘723 .1711: F: i_2:?,.<12:f;i‘=ln
“Mirnw Canzz'zuy :‘:.r upon any :Ffiairsl? xr: ““f :17" that Camp-::ny.
15211:: (Tariff-1:: {31:71:11}, ,3.-01.11.1151? 1r: T:.‘r:f"‘:7.Tr?‘-‘Io "9‘1““ Ci)‘"§'{33}"z:f, 2‘: far-:.‘;
11:1 ﬁho 5111::1r'm-prn; ﬁrm-111w“. it: tilt? '3 312-51 3‘?“ :mr": 5hr officer’s IL"\:‘.;‘:3111"1‘1
5'é1-“:'?’°:‘t=0* of 775. :1: 111-3:72 (2::: .132" 5::-:18, {511m'*v'11’:51.
3713 511:.713101‘ﬁ 0‘3" r”: :‘:fe'mﬁ {-1116 ' a?‘.:»1:im {131.2111 ‘thz‘, att:1rrucy of

17:37:: ‘1':1::~:"3:r':g§*f;c;21 F Envisrnrt‘; Faijviizf" ’51::11335'111y $1519: nab ﬁlms-02.3? 11:3:—
twig-:’: '1 32' 2.~:r‘zv:‘1>1<»d (1713' ﬁrm ‘inntt’lﬁtztiam 0'1: nrrnf’nr‘icg-r 1.‘} this: 6521:7113, the:
1':::*.!"'r.::r"r-1§g_:;'-:':(‘. a,::‘-'1'fizL*3‘1'r'J, 53:17:221rv1 3'5. 1'7"??_<§_r:1.:, smeltea-i: 1:11:11", he 1:313:00
botany"? (if 37:2“:- f-’:€>X'irzgj:f:3:f r"; 5151*.3‘131’23m 13:11? 1:73;] ilg-mpnragi, mm as 1:11.311
3:12:51 3?2r*‘.a:g_j:> ‘ r1747 ::gfzﬁﬁf’wn an? 1*“ in 7:.1yn’atéz- Cmmf‘qy 2:613:72“:
tr) 0:" affecting; said Fu’ﬁdhgf‘qrgﬁ 5‘: ‘Tasmorzz ""szj'.11zr:23r (farm-my. :"zf—
té‘i‘.a21‘:7 1311374511111: :z‘iratms. that h? ‘nn $14170 1’ :10 aatnzﬂ no 1:100 or
}7"i-')Va’:i.4"‘C-Ygfi‘v 3:? the 3.1'1£?+}i.{317.tf3">3'7 of 1.73111 prnsrvit :2:-.111; or of the ser-
vino 93'? any 5211112112118 thwroin upon th': lexingﬁmn E: "Cass‘arrz'n 3:117 12
Company 031131312 :‘r‘bhm' Cary, thn Z’roaﬂdnn‘b 0:? Hair} Company, 0‘
upon any athnr official of 5; 51111 Company 1121“? 11:11:62 on the m

 .
. _
‘O
._,5.“,
411086357, Dcoumbcr :25, 13355, :;1153 that on the .7.-vexing; of
'33 “7'"‘17-"7- ’3'-i5'3. H2515: :'.:"f?:.:-2'i; rurrv'ivm'i z: ’L.-qtrr frar: the
A
“:'ftf.’:F.-tr ' :': 3:? 15:5. :1 7 ::";£‘21'1£G“f‘.rt':'-'2 8: ”1. 371-1 32.-3.11 1 was? Comrnmr
‘3 :’rii‘Xi-Eﬁ:f\“3'3'?1. 32137319105127, $1539.11 that '52: 7.":1113-1'135/2 ‘.';hc
331.531 7337 <7? 3"=“2*-‘-¥’1“)£-‘.-". WE'VE, «’1 :211rnr'm'12'3 in this: z;")0“.r:7—-s:":;77~:-CL
‘ 3.23:3 31'3"} M93“- 9‘71'5’5‘3 "ﬁg-"l". ‘3'-‘,:?1722‘ 551117, ‘:Ezr: .‘?:c'. ::ia1v:::-‘b of
{77’1“ 'S'T‘=Xi"‘-i‘.f"ccn ‘7': Vistas: ?<:‘-.'7__1w:1.,‘ 6713333215}. "7211s: affiim‘b,
rs: RC 1’: 17:15:71.“€9.17le 9:11“ Ii; '51:?! :V‘-t h’xi'i :3,-.‘:."33; sti‘i‘.:_,-":33=:I";i
':-:':-"7331371939": ‘30 :’3-1'4 17011 :3:L"‘1::Z,.i.' "in: 3,“—ween? 311i“: shit-1116..
“ :11". u :‘:r : I- Lo ”5%.? “twat/1 8c
Vii-‘“"ti-z’ifn 3‘-) \ ny' .:tfaru: :".:2‘; 37"f7'1'3f Emit"! “':,mlﬁzm‘ga‘:
3216‘; ‘.1-31']: arm} “: :':?aimaa 6:; km: Zavri'umrr"; 33:! 3
1512:“ wir:.i2;’.‘ii‘f, 57(77‘13"(‘ér'.' 73af31’Lum'. "may“. 37.“;r7’03fraom if {it 6,11;
. "”’-‘73 311’ 3m0‘i'r: 1;:‘3 {fl-”PTGE'I ’Tx.:::3117‘ 3'37".“ 35:31: 5,.-j” the 30711331771330 5‘:
13F~Thviliéc 7133.1? 1:1-.”1 C'ﬂ’d,£‘iii‘ri-’7IJ’ TIT: m:- :’:"?{LZE' 477:1 City of Com.
3.“L:;""if.3'.‘i on 135.211“; 12:11:39.5. on. The :.‘:fifﬁsz :‘.: states that ﬁlm '.(zlxzméL
V3553" 8° 3”“5'Ll’3‘7-17T- 135i '3313'1‘117 ".“-"u=_=;_>a: {if it: 5:; 1'.;‘1~31:":‘.::a«7 comatmation
‘3‘3305-339’7‘7 “'3‘-.‘3 (’..'? 5’ 1:13.20?) ;Ea'rm the T‘ aim/'11? " 3351:}1vi719 "ail“
"'iih‘if’? i3=‘3m3‘)zz.r1:r aw? 31:79; 3.53.“, “937.31%: (.;.;'L~,-,;-:1g;, :’.‘z‘cam 5;:-..:; CH3; of TH}?
:.H‘Tt‘m in an 1’5’-’=“3-‘-‘¥‘7l.17 5.:-:16: :~-~,z_tf;hs“-:.~.:.:this}? direction into .‘ﬁmth-
“"3“ K 537331931537" :1:-tr? “iii-3a": ﬂir: {mi-:1 Traditizton :’.; Faster)". T317—
‘-'-"€v?;" CIR-”173122.”:g' ham no line or ‘7 111m; $171 :15: 2131* f:‘§1x-‘..rz.z:r_-:If!..‘;f from
3'7'3513WTW‘73’1 1” '1=1:’—=‘.'.’h~:c°»:‘. '35:; 1:120 WM :31" Cmrisug.ftr321, Priozmmer. or
’7 1?.-’5»? 1'1""..‘3FJJ’213: .713 Tints-.‘: 1;: z): Shift r3710. Ci‘ar of Coviraﬁmn.
This CHE-€3.17? f; fuming-z- chat 3 that as; soon 618 11c
91711.3 Cemvczzimzﬂy (“so :”.) he can "miea‘asrzzi With the 1005‘s.? offi-
01521.9: an 35:51:55.5? of the? 7702:521514501'1 ("=3 Theater]; Railway (fora-ban?
“775 :"3011;?,ht from +n infﬁl‘i‘lnti/YIZ emf: aﬁvice rmzprctingir the
07:35»; of the pig-3,.izwifi', mam 39.31am]. 831,3 plaintiff in thr
. 1‘33“"53'1'Tilt' 31172.45, but that such infemution £7216. arlvico came- to
him aft-7r the rz-tnrlition “:3;; the Court 01" its Juvisz'mnt harem

 .
.‘ -
O
__4‘_ -
[‘24-‘333311125 ,ijur‘tn-zjr Mates 13.3.1318 sahol'izl‘uzf after rr-cr’iviszg
55-71:» '§3:.‘-.z‘-;-"‘:-1;zhim ;-.‘.'r’.n-.r.;~ 1151013;- CL he. nos-.‘:; :20 15111:. 3-11, of firsuiro
‘Ez‘ﬂaaz-rE, 1:; Jazz‘tiar‘ 2.21:" that T113:- ;;-j:‘ Taytﬁﬁsc. 5133121333, before
3:31.323: 217E113: S1151; Em". ".3-13273 :12:::t.iy-:1;'?:-‘-~I and 2731:: ;2-“126113'1g; and vrvrbally
I eff-f3") 5231313 37-1. 22:33:; 37.: "tics: bf thri- “195-129 ci':“<3um:1€;a'r,cr:s 2711:2031
13:.2-‘3. ;‘2r(::'-,:‘::-;‘!:-“-i 15h 1.1115"x‘t.‘-3_,_':‘:-;‘:3. .::.‘i'f‘iezatiz 311:": ;Li-IT‘L-L,’ ’Jh-‘E r1‘:(§“.1i:3itc
:.:/rib"nt‘ir-‘r: 3::- J-IT‘LEs; r “3?; .;.-1d '.'L'.-:.-1'"..u:*oa 3:211:- :.-;':'::.Z '17-’33“: 21113;"! b’"f-ﬁ')1‘ff
iii-.ir: '2? “2'53 ”’:-.‘.:er- :3 mac-1333‘: ":.: .':-'3': 21131113: “551:1 default
312‘- -_'_;"-. 31': 1131;?" 1’2‘331‘31' ‘ '.; 3:1“er .’“131‘f5317‘ ::n’bing of E?
31.11; “"3, 51.361 :3523‘ r1 73.2-3431}. 1.2 ﬁlthy-1.3124311: ‘.'"217" 3:; said Jutrtico
311‘ the-,- "(22213-1 .' :71}: ‘_.'"'-' 1‘. ' ;2.‘ 41:» “:‘xi. :1". Fri 212237.
,“=,‘-=’"T‘:".‘.«E.‘Z" T81 731"”), :3.L: J :1 13"} “~37? 1, 17.1127: ;3.f_f';3‘..‘."-.t further
51751315313: {ff-.":? EC .': jyz'w't'n‘i 3:? i;i'.‘ a: 53:177....53 Ens-“:1" “215,313.31
£1211 ,7 331-”. {Ez'igfsei- .2131: :.‘r: :1»: 61. :13; 177:1}: 23 2.3117 “ft” 10.? ‘EEIH
33737;? 0:? ”viz-m, 3 '.1 a:‘-.'.i13j_ .3:”: 1:13-2:1msition
iii-1: 73.3.1533 6.62.131: 33:. 117311-1321? 2.2212 11:33.: proifs‘ﬂ"; €1.13 E113 office
“’:-‘.1 ‘21:; 43311.3; 4 211-"- ‘zhn. 22"3'233211'17 1131-.“ "its" W in“??? was also
‘T: .":-=33 ﬁi1le‘f‘ was ﬁt: L!"g‘}’.)-"'?"f3‘.“:fz'7 1 s: :3.-23:13'311; 31'
221-11". ‘.1-1' "7735? :1- 33353‘310L, 'UP: :13“? 713': "3'21; :.‘7'2';'_';L'Lt 37:13 1111321317 and
~3‘:‘.:3'.1*; 3n??? 3.151111? ‘5;- rain. 7'! ":.::ifix-(1.1.5131r”: :33:- ffner fzrtatcs that
“1:31-17 :33-3:13:72 3‘2“” 35": him 3'33] ithz“: rﬂ‘i‘ﬁ. Gr“ 71:. mm”. £11.."“71‘E: of
1’13113 T-(‘Xingtmz 8: “i€:.:_ste..3::-1 31%? 37031133222; .-3"-*':?§:5';r:‘-.:2; :.:-”‘i't'aa-Jzt of the
'31'22151‘317111113021 and 3::-1.119%" 31:19:; :3.‘ #3119 viii"; din? 11:31.: 1‘ " affiant's:
:31“ :31? an '53::‘r'3r-gh 313:4: 22:13.79 1111131213 z;.:.:'a;:."; .21" :11..- 3.1;; 11:5 'L‘mmday, 3‘0-
CHEF-“7TH” 32”.", 797?: Fizz“: 13319171313113.11y 01". 3:115: 33:13:19 (littf), affiazzt had
“‘:,Vi'f-i 5;: :‘. 2111;; 33;-T5436: am} -‘.:::a‘:.“z"11<>rl the ma 31 «Erlivor-s’w‘ {m that
no 3.1511215: anti, after (3.01321; :33, 11238.. 3:132”; the (3:11:37 of 'exiz‘zgtan
5231307114.; 9 0’0? 303:: .’ for "23130 C3333] of Enniwviii 11>; that {azrffiant
was: ubgmt from 3the City of War-:.ington 8.25.3. of sniﬁ ‘3?=..;rt:3v‘say,
Doc-"ﬂoor 25, 7, and. Mr] 1104-; r-r'ttztrn to 3:110 {1.1.4:}; of 11‘03211223ton
frat-3. the City of "Deni :3viF10 111135211 about 5! o’cficmk on the night

 ‘_
O
. -—b~- -
of saii Tx-sﬁuy‘ T 0»mhnr f5, F915; that affiant than vjaitnﬁ
‘ his affiee ﬁﬂn {my uhw first time rﬁawivoﬁ ﬁnﬁ rand ﬁhn afore—
saii ?eﬁt r giving 33% ihfwrmnﬁiwn 3f fhe fiiing of thr above—
:tf3oﬂ tuit, ﬁffiurf ﬁﬁtfﬂﬁ fhnt as hp thvx for thr first time
Bisrovnrnﬁ ﬁhé Hu~mnn, in t“iw ;ui? Lad ﬂown made rvturnabﬁn
921 ’:‘-.,;..-.:".z?:;;', Burrs;:37-'::,- :2“:, HEEL}, :.:: 3:2". \‘)'{3711.f1.:':. 5:," m 170:? :it'
’ B'cann appu?~nt tn the affinnﬁ +heﬁ & hearing wné trial if this
Ci‘if'r’. 3:21.11 Bren had 3);" 533V: Vitrifimi- (W? 3;};‘(2- “Warm :‘.1-mire ‘_’1121’ F:./"—
Tart ?Wiﬂ Ir‘tvr and ﬁﬁﬁ Cﬁwﬁvnts chum~ knﬁwn to ﬁhﬁS mf?iant.
‘.".Im 17:):iie:r'-;~:‘agra-"v6: ;szs'tizizi’; ‘:‘" thuﬁ 'bhix 312$“? 3.;.6’:
Evy Crfwhww proper $0 an interpOQvﬁ hzrrgr on behalf of the
ée’ﬂnéaat, T ﬁﬁSVﬁﬁﬁe ﬂ ﬁsvhviﬂ a 9&ﬁ7roaﬂ Cowyaxyf gr an hchalf
of the L”Kiig$0ﬂ % ﬁaﬁtrr: iajlwvy ?mmpeny, 3f which Cnmpany
’ thjr aifﬁsxt i3 attorxpy, have fajﬁvﬁ to ?PﬁfiVC ?hc rnqtﬁsite
' atﬁéntion fram the afiﬁant or}; ﬁnnpuwe a? 11H m aewsarg absence
absence from 3h: City of aninfton and becaumr sf his fgiiﬂrc
f0 zr‘cwiin‘ timejgr nnfdirr Pr 334$"7wfgxé if {#9 fililyy 0f 'thiS s3uit .
shi ﬁhe asFifnmcxt wi’rrw: far trial as afcrfsaid on the morn- ‘
iﬁb of Tuoeﬂay, ﬂvecmber Va, 1915‘

Thu uadnynignné affiant Eu thnr Rfﬁteﬁ ﬁnat aw he is
aﬁviSvi, if the aefrndant, iouixvillo a Nuahvilla Railroad
Company,hw grantnd a nun trial heroin, it has a awed and sub-
stantial Grfcnsr to ﬁhv w75untiff'ﬁ claim nndi with a reasonable
opparﬁunﬁtj to Re 80, can uqﬁ wiTV ptncura watncxgws to establish
itC 3?id ﬂwfvnsn. ?Hw undorsignﬁd uffiant status that in con-

, tradiotion of tha GLﬁjm a~rortnd axﬂ su*d upon by ﬁhu plaintiff,
Tanroo ﬁallarf, the defendant iw proparhd to prove, if given
a raawwnablm opportntity to as so, that said Konrwo Sallard is
mat anﬁ has not bvmn in thﬁ nn Sis-

, 97 V“V“' 7‘5‘ iilif= :;?:Ti::3 % :;1:? 23' ‘::? J Jive) ;2; a»: j:% ixﬁz>w":ri‘)i e 1333? ‘tiro
ﬂyfrwiuxf by iﬁs ;tﬁérn'y 1~ ;‘V: “:- =3 ,nwginfa n@%:ﬁticx
“f; ':.?k!‘ ﬁé."77?115'?.“ :"i 7_‘}:"i"? “371?.

'V‘-‘,»; 7.-’.‘-:§“‘.Lj"tf“: C" Y: 5 +7755: 7511‘: 31:5; :'fg:12‘;'t:‘:,;:;v,‘, "3‘31: iﬁi‘;
maﬁcrngﬁsﬁ ﬁlﬁcrr’y, ?FTiicf "ﬁalvu tug? it? chul ﬁfent aﬁé
I5TT“FFI*??iv; in ”rxir‘tn: £33 FGEVFi~ C,rnﬁ? 3f the Touifvillé
? VERﬁVi??? ﬁﬁfWTC=ﬁ Czwfcrj 1H *2: 3. 7. C333 ;:f that any
<1 vans 0r noﬁica int :5?! fr? 2L3R ’wwicri??w 5 Farhvﬁilc
?O‘Fera-‘I qu‘rrnﬁaz‘3y 01331313 jay‘ppgjy? I?" ”H:- r“; .~j,_ '34.??? ,~ 4'50 53%“ REEVES
Ryan vaiﬁ E. B. Carr as 2hr cg n? #7 a??? 'gcigvi??r 3 Task»
Vi?1n ﬂailycaﬁ Cdewny‘ #ffiar? Turti I ufrf a t?aﬁ tha

' :77:{‘1"F’:.5"{1-"i mfﬂjiﬂr? ai‘ﬂ-r‘ +7}"f' ff-fjath~r._4; TLC-1“} 3’;:‘-;"_{: ﬂy} 3_; 11.11301“: {:1? 4;: 3..-Fe
fil ﬂ as much on beh33§ 3f tho Tcxirg3~1 ? Tant<1m ?a41w3y
Company as on behaﬁf if thﬁ Tatinvich E Tayhviilr feilrdad
Company; that said wcuiaviﬁlc ’ Rashviile Railroaé Cmmpaay,
a: hvrnin have explain a, has never b“9ﬁ duly or yrsper‘y
summonef as a ﬁcfwnd It in this action and naié 10x 3 to: F
Tastnrn Lailway Company upnn WhOﬁC Prrsié at the summons was
acﬁually SFTVCd. i3 mat a party ﬁn this suit unﬁ ought ngﬁ to
be procccdoﬁ against hnrcin for any purpose whatsoever.

 4
r?
I..—’_-
1 JJ.. ..'3'" _ .'. . ‘ .~. . , t. I
Mung-:1 21.1.113‘» 17:13.1“: stab.
“_wmmmwnm
1“’ L . ﬂ .. 7 q .,. ,. ._.», ;— ...’?“ _,. . _ - "' — . A .' “ _ '.‘..“ ,A‘
._:»,Lér;.u;{'. 11:-.l.; --.;-,s;‘ ..:; ..'{?J-U,,F 5731* UV 545310. .“1 {13311,
W . v .. .- . . ,
7’7 ,' “ "."‘,u, ;'L' ‘2.. ‘...‘ , - 1' L ,I _. ., '
Julian; . x ;4.-'1 w:- :-:-._‘« .,': L-n-qur; :Y' IQ} l ’I?,
v ~ --1,-... .. ‘ - ~ 4 ~ ---
..“-”‘.;wa . '.“
» ,. A .II” t . ,. 7 -
.. . .. my: V.‘ ?.3'0L_nty,;7q,7.