xt77wm13ng0p_44 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt77wm13ng0p/data/mets.xml https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt77wm13ng0p/data/51w15.dao.xml unknown 6 Cubic Feet 9 boxes, 1 item archival material 51w15 English University of Kentucky The physical rights to the materials in this collection are held by the University of Kentucky Special Collections Research Center.  Contact the Special Collections Research Center for information regarding rights and use of this collection. Caleb Powers papers Assassination -- Politics and government -- Kentucky. Conspiracy -- Kentucky. Affidavits Statesmen. Lawyers -- Kentucky. Challenges, Motions, and Affidavit Relating to Jury Selection text Challenges, Motions, and Affidavit Relating to Jury Selection 2017 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt77wm13ng0p/data/51w15/Box_5/Folder_1/4303.pdf section false xt77wm13ng0p_44 xt77wm13ng0p 1 a
SCOTT CIRCUIT COURT.
Conmunwealth of Kentucky ' Plaintiff
vs. ChalW cor ,magw " ‘ Special
Ven'iJA, n NOW‘QG 'C-guaeh anﬁ. Discharge the same.
Caleb Powers, Defendant .1
The aefe1ndmntJ Caleb Powers new omes ancl enters hie challen e
to the Secong = ~:'~.:.:; :-‘— -; ‘~-~*--:t‘n-~.-W“'-“"W , said See-anew
W Mal/32M 190‘. .
Mae Originally reported consisting of one hundred £7115; thingy
four men, all of whom have been eeleeted and eunmeneﬂ by the Sheriff
aml Deputy Sheriff of this Court frem Grant Ceunty pursuant tn. an
orﬂer tf this Court entereﬁ herein 110% 20th 190‘?9 and the members
W
of which Seeend appeareé anal
reporteﬂ for cluty in thie Cour-t on Menﬂay, 11511111111091» 25th 190?; aml
before the examination of any of eaiﬂ venjnemen on their voir dire
is begung defendant moves the Ceurt t0 quaeh sale eeeené W
WSpeeial Venine anﬂ to ("lieeharge each and all of the
men composing eaici Second W Venire npen the
ground of substantial and prejudicial irregularities upon the part
of said offi care in eelecting and summoning said Seem-Cl m
W811e0§.a1 Venire am? the several members thereof and
he avers that the irregularities eem‘plaineﬁ of are more specifically
set out in defendant's affidavit herewith filecl in sunnent of his
"present challenge ancl metien.
Defenﬁant further avene anﬂ ehangee that the sale Second W
W Qpeeial Venire returned herein On Monday, November
.
25th 1907 and the eitieene compee‘ing same, are not impartial nor
have they, or any of them, been fairly 01" impartially selected or
faiily or impartially summoned by the offi eere charged. with the
rluty of seleeting and eumwning eaid. veniremen within the meaning:
0:? the Constitution ancl lane :33? Kentucky 8.1151 the Genetitution ef‘
the United States and the several amendments thereto; that fully
three fourths ef the men eompeeing said
MEpeeial Venire axe membewe of the Demeeratic Pant}? “a in
affiliation therewith, anfl ha‘re been an-i are warm friends and
,

 " 1
-3-

admirers of the late William Goebel, and that they were in his lifeo
time ardent partisans and active supporters of said Geehel, Defend“
ant avers that but for ihe unlawful discrimination on ﬁhe part sf
said officers in selecting and summoning said venivemen, as complain—
ed of herein, a large proportion, temwit four ninths or nearly one
half of the entire number thereof” should have been and would have
been White male citizens of said county of Grant possessing all the
necessary legal qualifications for jury service and who, at the same
time, have been and are” members of and in affiliation with the
Reﬁubliean party, the pariy wiih which defendant has been and is now
identified, and defendant evens that to require him to be tried by
a jusy composed wholly, or in mart, of men ﬁaken from said Second
Sémésﬁuhgisewsﬂrig§g&-Special Venire will be in violaiien of the
Constitutdnns and laws aforesaid and will be a deprivation and denial
to the defendant of due presses of law and the equal preteetien of
the laws as secured and guaranteed to him by the Constitution of
the United States and particularly by the 14th Amendment fhereef and '
by the law of the land.

The defendant now ﬁherefere moves the Court fer ﬁhe reasons and
upon the grounds hereinbefere staked and set ferﬁh and more fully
stated and set forth in defendant's affidavit herewith Filed to
sustain his sai%%::§l;enge to said Second 3sésiséwa~e€~$u§é~¥héa&,/

3 Special Veétgezieturned i to ﬂaunt on Monday Nov. 25, 1907, and to
quash and discharge said veniremen ferthwith from jury service herein.

Defendant asks leave t0 introduce and offers to introduce the
evidence of certain wifeesses and certain other evidence besides his
aforesaid affidavit in suonort of the nresenﬁ challenge and motion,

All of which challenge and metioh ﬁhe defendant is ready to and
does hens and new verifyo (?23 

Signed and swarm to befere me by said affiant, Caleb Powers,
this 261321 day Of liovember 190?. ﬂ/Z ' '

i Z i/ W. Meow
67L Wot/LT’QW/LM
(
» /

 CZM «VD/Z6 /W% ,i
J ((02 6/574 / L } kit »
i ‘ wﬁ: / “1*zW% M . _,
@6966 t“ VIM/LO ‘ ‘

 530T? CIRCUT? US$11.
GWTUETQEﬂﬁﬁﬂlﬂﬁﬂmﬁf Piﬁﬂﬁfﬁl
Vi; , (35’ I AXLE”.- fj‘jii'S‘Céﬁ 1 in: 3'3 F TC; {if if: :’ $317." 1.
CifkTJ’“? 37C? 13': 7.77. 3; .3: Jillijfé 1
m m a M m 1 3
’1 :3.Q:E‘@h;l 11:3,; @1253?) \ 7.2:? 3:::625; ﬁnd {1:11; FY73“; 17111:": :.,:
2‘ 1:15.11 “w“ to 11 3:34:33: 1,123.. 111:0 9 1253:; 7:930:1’: N1": r1105“? 5 SHIT-.”BVIIE 21:1
frmﬂ'ﬁarrison Gaunt: far BHM*“JJQ;1’UVTKESF 331W} 1T37§ and WQVQS ;
Elﬁn; maid.gﬁﬁeciaﬂu'venzre caui 333;: 311 a: nrfzjamb: :'iﬁer‘ri'31€ di$w '
' charged upon the foiluwinx ﬁrnunds, ﬂoaﬂit; that the offisarg of
$335 Cﬁﬁft dirncﬁed ﬁe ﬁiﬁﬁﬂﬂ a spacial venire from Farrisan oounﬁg
by arder'af this court antered in this causegﬁizrghals”: ZTGV, aaa
1
Wha werq gent by ﬁha aheriff sf ﬁhig ceunty, t3 gcrfotm aeid sore
vise did notifairly gag imijﬁially parfnrm their dutiﬁa and,ﬁave
net fairly anﬁ imﬁﬁrﬁiagly'selecfed or guvmonﬁea Said jurorg ﬁuﬁ,
upon the smﬂtrary, illegally and in vinlmﬁioﬁ 0f the sﬁmﬁuteg 13d
caustiﬁution of ﬂmiﬁ Gangemmaalth ﬁﬂd in vialaﬁien ﬂf the K: his
securﬁd t0 this dn*en¢ﬁnt as a ciﬁinen 3f Kenﬁuck: sﬁd 39 a citizen
1 of the Unitad Stataa, auger ami hr virtue 9f ﬁze Caustiﬁuting mf the
Unitea Stateg, 1nd ﬁarticuiirly in vinlaiien of ﬁha riﬁltg ﬁacure3
to Him by €33 14” muendmeat 3f ﬂta Comatitutioa 3f tin Uﬁiﬁmd,ﬁi1tag
, £13 salect and sum nn'aaid jurerﬁ and arch cf thaw, and ﬁne amid
mfficﬁvg did emngcinuglj 1nd purpngel? ﬁwlnct jmrara NE a aiffaremt
yaliﬁioal 3ffiliniinn frnw 1&9 pnliticai affiliation 6f 61% dafaﬁﬂanﬂ
and wersnnallﬁ hastile ﬁn ninjané fhiﬁ ihﬁj 3:3 wiﬁﬁ tha purraim 0f
discriminating againat the dsfen33ntﬂ anﬂ with £30 Jesign aw1 inien-
ﬁiou to depriva the dﬁfﬁﬂdﬁﬂt Who is a citizen 3? Vewtuckv an‘ a?
, . .v .1 ..", . w ~.1-
thg Unitad Biates nf ﬁia right 10 a fair and inpartial trial hf aﬁ
tqparti3l jury imyaytially'3elﬁcﬁed, 13 Juarunieed by the lﬁWﬁ and
canaﬁituﬁion 0f Hantmcky and ﬁne Cnmsﬁitution 0f ihe United Staiam
and the 3mandmemts tHETGtﬁ

 . t,”
i
find Defendant for :‘i‘urt?;r2r ,gground of challxnge, we? s and
charges that the said. spec 3123,}. veriire and eaei and every :membe I“ there-
of as.” s not inmartial irritiriin the meaning; of the. Constituti on and. laws
of Kentucky and the Con stitutien of title limits-d filtetes and, me. several
Amendments 11h er eof , and to require F1511 ta he tried “by jury composed
of men taken from. said 3;:eeial venir's will Tee in violation of the
Unmet ituﬁons and laws aforesaid. 19.315. it? 13. he a. denial to the defend-ant
of due prowess of law and. or.“ the soil protection at" the laws, as
{guaranteed him by “31 6 Constitution of the 'Ejnited St ates and p articu-
larly by the 14" smimmt thereof.

{the Defmdant now, therefore, iiimres the court for the
reasons and upon the ;_;rounds Eiereinbefore stated and. set forth to
sustain his said. challenge to said special vanire and to (15.538113??ij
said sa'izaeial venire forthrrit‘h.

And in suggwort of“ his aforesaid challenges :11in motion, the
defendant tenders liermrith 213?. 9 awn suffidaxirit and certain other
aff’i dava 1: s .

2.

 SCOT??? CIRCUIT COUI‘L’J.

CO.“ 7‘03"”[132133532 OZ? :':..TYTT'UCZCY PL.«.‘;1':"‘TI?F‘.

’.F'C’. 01’ '2.!3I33'..IZTC}3553 1‘33 7 ‘0’: IOU.
ZULU"? 1‘07". LLB,” I 33335133.” 73.15;" T.

.. .. .. .. _ .. ..

The defendant, Hale‘s 2170:3533 3, c ONCE 5,130. 6214:2335 “3:11:93 .
0316311611456 to 433316 5313931333. venire , 2:;1C each. :f'zezcﬂiser ﬁllers-:0? , 51113223013 L».
1" Tom Tia.2~r*i.so13 Comsizg' Jim ......:-.;.- _, T‘ovczgzicver' ”._,“, 190?, and. no Ire-S
2,319.2 52316. 83603131 35913.11? and. Mes and. ova-3‘17 231-3273717533:- ‘tl‘m‘r‘coff "are dis—
charged. 1.311073 the f 017 02:71:35; {;1“:;:1:.1‘1.C15;, ﬂaw-zit; “3:1": 2;.‘3'. the ofﬂcr- of
“ti: court (Li'r'c-scted to SLEZ'YI‘JIUH : speci :31. vehir‘e 3'?er Ff:1‘:"1";'i.sr313 comfy

’W W
by 01:51.83? Of this court cerz‘t.c-1‘r‘:C. in this 02213.5(): Ali-2;”. 212.3”, 1’90'3’, 321.6;
/\
1113.0 were sent 23;: the 5311c: Tiff cf 'iii‘é'sis C(sustﬁgz, “Le pariah: said. :.rzr-n
vii: 23. did. not? 1'" 3i 1*] ; 23333.1 3111313233331 3.11;." 1332.:1'tf(.~1*::: flu-2:13" duties and. ”L
not 3:353:13,»- aiiul isgqn‘ilii 2313.3" selected. or” £31.,u‘.'1‘:’::....1u;3. this “they; did. with the {311.23%ng (f
(ii S()1"I'L1i-123.l“l_a”t ing against‘ the CLe:“er.:,C3.r-3.nt, and. with the Ceasign 21,.2’sCL interl—
tion to deprive the defendemt: what; 3.9 :3, citizen. of 73192321113313", and. of
the United. States- of ”the 1*;‘13211; £0 a. fwil’ 33nd. i:s,x.pa.1“'ti23.l trial by an
i7:'1};.2s..3:'%.;':22.l jury 111-11.» initially select ed, as guarauzt 0.00; “:33“ the laws 5:316.
consti't uiuicm 01" Kentucky 29.116: the O‘on .: 3'. MIL: 5.01:. of the United. Stat as I
and the 3111611637. out 3 ’i;.}*3.el‘-C"Z:o .
;I‘
\
.

 - . . 53,.“

And Defendant for further‘ground of challenge, avers and
charges that the said special venire and each and every manner there-
of are not impartial within the meaning of the Constitution and law§
of‘Kentuoky and the Constitution of'the United States and ﬁze several
Amendments ﬂiereof, and to require him to be tried by a.jvry composed
of men taken from said special venire will he in violation of the
Cbnstituions and laws aforesaid and will be a denial to ﬁle defendant
of due process of‘law and of‘the equal protection of itw'qua, is
guaranteed.him by ﬁre Constitution of the United States and particu»
larly by the 14" Anemxnmit micreof;

The Defendant now, therefore, moves the court for the
reasons and upon the grounds hereinbefore stated and set forth to
sustain his said challenge to said Special venire and to disohamge
said Special venire forthwith. ‘

And in support of his aforesaid challenges and motion, the
defendant tenders herewith his own affidavit and certain oﬂien
affidavits.

, 2.

 Vl
friends, foll ()WGl'S, 9.63.1 er cents, ell;.r_;’.-01I"lz 01‘s and. admirers of said
rt 4 T g 1
UOCOG_.
He states that he is ill/folilled 3.116. believes and. elm: es ”that
; F. r . ./ ,—7‘" J F
. ’ 7../I“ . / _N- 3 .. _ .--
_..- WW - .‘. . .‘f ifﬂgiiﬁlu-‘I- __KFA. 4W7: W364 We O-el-ILI-‘w
//
sheriffs of BC oti‘. County, Z-Lel’ltllclzy, who sv211u”1o/l’l,_ ,.., 1. *‘ “_-_
11:11:05 th at said ”___ __ m ..“..-N 31151 ..._. . _ “1mm..- ‘_ _4 _ or one of them,
I‘ ac comp ::ni ed by said W _ 11.1.11“- - -., -3, and. “...1-..“ - - _> ___me or one
of 1211 62111; p e. :3 seem“ -1.,M,.._...-._..-...M. -_M “_.,..-- -111...” ,-1. - _. _ 17... __M
“'.}?ﬁuﬁl‘ec311131*‘3?\76“r“7“" ”""”—’""””"”’ """””"w ""”""‘W" ““"“
Republic za,1'1§/a11d all of” 11110121 '.'rer e (3 C121}; et ent and legally qual if 1 ed
juro rs ,vand e1 ea ‘5 ed and smumned only _ _,-., .__.M.-._.--...--..-,-. -.-_”. 11.,
al 1 of $111021}. :11 e Demo or at e and 1:1 art i een 9.6111, erent s and Ewan. here of" the
late 7.2’1'.llism'1 Goebel and that til e aforezw can't ioneo. Republic-€211 s and
Independent 301:1.ocrat 5.! re side on this part of caid ..._...1-” _> .: ”-_1-.._.l..__.
_..“ "U” -111-.- _, ”4'9 ikee rim 1" e “(21 e aforerrzenti once. De::*.ocrat S re s ide that
were select ed and sm'mloneo. He ism/s £11 at on the ___.t’m “_-__... pike
the said ___. ”___“ ””“ and 11.-.- _- ,- _‘ ,__ or one of th 6511, ac (1:01:13; 11:32 ed.
by :'.sai'c‘i. __ -1 -- ....- __ and. ___ﬁ ___.,M,_1___.-___ or one of them , palesed and
purpo eely and. 11110111 ugly :f‘ 3.13 ed; to sutuz'zon ___-mm“ W __ ,7- ﬂ _ _ --, - .‘..
-‘:. _ _ _ “._- __ _, -. ,1..- _ _ __-, who were Republicans or 111er enoent Demeorats
and. c 01:13; e 11 ant: and legally (111.211 ifi‘ erl jurors and 81311113011266; 0111;." ..“...
Demo crate and 13111131 ean adh erents and. admirers of" 1111 e let :3 ’.Yilliem
Go 6:71 el. He says th at. the a;i‘<_>re::1entioned Republicans and Indep ondgnt
5 u

 Der;10r;1‘a.ts reside on that part of said“ __IIIIIIIIIII_IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII pike Whereas»
the aforesaid Democrats reside that were selected and. stu‘baz'roneri.
He says “:21 at on the ..._.--w....-.,.._1_:.1:..n IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIItulmpilces
that said, _IIIIIIII I I . . _IIIIIIIIII and I I I I I I I .. I I I I I I or one of
til em, “0 e07'1'9a311'1m51 by said: _IIIIIIIIII IIIIIII IIIIIIIIII and. IIIIIII I II I _I I I I . _ I III or one
0‘3 57331337351595» ”mull.” . . . . , . . . . , . .. . ,. A . . . . - .‘V-<-M...._An-1,_v_ H.. l , .- ,. .__.
IIIII I I I I I I I I I I II I I I I I I, all a? '::/31015: ::er': Republicans 01" Ifld.=3::€1‘1i}:e milk :"9 the
::L:.“01":::::1<3':1t 3‘.me 301.1061" alts 1‘ :3 side '11). ::t were select-32:1 '11 am: 1221011 0:1.
320 f 1.1761121 er says t‘glﬁtelt ; $118.. :‘.1': .':Ui":"_r,':'r1f'.rag: 21:" 03‘s in
n: 0 ”0:21:11“: Com 93? Val‘r'igou. . .1
., 1 "t ”'3 '* #"‘v_2_/" ‘-"“ J 2110.61.10dS of/selectlvlg and. 5L122110:‘11113
only the :-L:lLe'r eat 5; 1.116. 'T‘L‘iemls sum-l ELLL‘YleT'fﬂ‘S of the late ’.Tilli 92:1
Goebel L: observer}. by said. ___IIII IIIIIIIIIII III and. ___IIII I . _, I - I . __ _ 01“
11., /

 'l
’ N
"1
0113 of them, and, 151211: waid 7 _. . 3.1111 ._ . _ ..H ..7. ‘».Wild. inbr'e—
111.133 said and t 0 ("3'1 3 1’31:- :3" 31" 53 0115 o:: 11y th. at _‘
1732-,er 3633:1031" 21135; known and also to be the :;’>r_-1r"s;:i;s.:111. 32513101" vents and.
admirers of the late Willi 3:11 Go 31331 3,111}. such only 33 inh‘od.L13-3zi,,
and. to @713 1‘3 3:11:131'133 of such .7:-1311 «yon-1y were 391,111 311:}, =
/ 43.23:,» ,
/ o chiblz . -
' T313 affiant yo 1:11.31: while the 011310 31 1‘33? erred; {main st.
him in the imiictrierat 113233531 is one of 111111;;(21‘, tn: notifiiii six—main;
this 1° act, 21,3 submits to the 337.11%; that it is 3131111041 sible for 11in
to :333111‘3 or 11 ave 11:1 at kin]. of 2331 i;11;:x;2,1“ti;—1TL trial ”33:30:33 33: 321.133: i121-
;15;1"'n‘;iall.y select 36., that is g;11:3*=121‘t3:.~3c1 to him 1111331” tlm Constitution
3111'}. 131.73 of the State "of 213111311313 3,115. the Co::13tit*1ti.o:21 31’? the T121133;
MA/Q‘ Eh 3W W30 »’wamkcw'mtd; Why/f»; box/1% _ Amy/3f MW?“ Lt? 191W
Stain-2:3!x 5301.21.61 tilt? Jumsjuergin 1132;332:11103 3:1" 119: m-m‘nmzs; 03; 311.123. 3
— - .a /
417; L3 bah/WW7 17 WW WM ‘ ,_ .
‘ ’ taken, fromftne 813331.311 V311 3.1“ 3: 3323133533113. 1: 1" 3312 the County 0.1: 1.13171 5311,
W selectecl and. 3111371311341, 3: aforesaid, 73;,“ (1):??f‘i331‘5 173.10 2331 act 323-. m , :3:
and 3113131111361 wit. 111 o 33 93133212.: for 31.1w; :.zcsrvic s», 1“an 313.1%? "33311 511111,
A ’\ 1
are the political 213.2131“ 3n ts 3,111. 3.311111” 211‘s 311.3. 311137531“; of th 3 late
”(Till 131:1 Goebel, 2121 ﬁche *’:U.1":;".33." of 1771:1311 this. fi’infiaﬂi‘; i 3 :133-11535; of
‘ ’ ”“”ﬁc WW
haying 373.1136. 311; .:z“r_13'€;+ed, amx/ "4’le 6m” m #73»; / ”7pm;
,- /, ‘74: 1 3'2 ¢—— "’";EX
W @MMﬂ'W/W‘W” LMﬁﬁn/wif ”AVW MIN JIM {/l/i/Vm/Iz 4451/9 ’ ,
[,2 T313 217131 "mt f v. 1“?311 31" 3:311:63“ til at 213 is 3. 051461283514 35111 1‘3 311137111
: / v
of the State of lierztuclqr 2111;}. citizen of the Unit, 52251 States“:
Subscribe; 3.31:], {3270231 to 11313413313 by (.7:-11373 :iv‘lozrc-‘cs, this the
7 _ 7 day of 101701113317, 1907.
,1 \ \
37f 1 , '7 7" / ‘ ‘ / 14v 3/ 7M”) 977/04"
— ‘~ / / ' 3 / , m I
WiW Maj/kiwi M/pgwwlﬂlvwc/ \ ~ / .2
” ' I ~ / [7 W '
W ' W / Wt“ VﬁL jM/su F) \
1 2 ‘73- 14 , f W/p
‘ Qv/ 2’ /' 1 'WC WV "WY W \7
m VIM/Mu , V , ' \ : ‘_‘ \
' /7 J 2 , .
’ ﬂ ' ’ ' ' i” W '27” y (”ﬂ/WnGJ WW
0" /, ,, W p ﬁ/ 42 n /
d//W4/IW ‘ M7 ~ $ / / , , / ,
.2 , 7 , 3L
/ ' <2 2 2/ WM ,1 , , A ,
/ , Kﬁ/ ,_ // ,L/V‘ ‘ ’ G *' W\ / "/ -\_
:97].Mz// M \’/ § ,
. Maia/w ”4 L/ (7 4 " ‘/ /
WW 0W” a. / I / / /
/ ,,/
’\
1
’ \

 .
..
.
-,~d~—'- -'.m .'.-._'”, ‘
1 (..‘) {1 u -v A, »' O . r i. but “1,1: J
.-v ~. __ .. qw, ‘.‘ ‘ ,. ’.‘ ' ..:. ’.....” . ..' ‘ .,j ..“,"
1* ,, L .. 7.. cu 1.9.x», t1 i :
.._,” . ‘ - r 7 “gm. " _1' .'w
293;!“ .“_” .' lw’u“; '~"’)u-Lr~
' ' / , M-
(£2 ./ v 4;, , c A ,' / , ”
rX/LM u “‘7/1/ —' “u "‘ / ,,.wZ/WwV/Ww a
,“ ..., ., .I. y, ~ .0,‘ . ..L ”.731 ,.n' :5:, » , ‘..... ,... J,- , ﬂMp/ 43- f. , .. ’1
\. x.“::.u.‘;£z .'.? (.-G.at;.'.:ud.11b r, ‘~ 64.1 J U -'-.'.‘.'. r2 , 3: _ . ,C, a”? E‘» . NC '..: '.x’ __5) L- LO =.3‘..31.’.C;
0’“~ , 7. ~
[/7 \/ vf/z/VLU «My?
.L {h .. ..I. .- , ..‘ ,‘JV 5. 3.... .{. ‘.. , (:_- ...dnl. I}... .. “._.: .,‘—,., :' .. . .‘..J. , ,_ M .CTI,,_ 4:
u .- (ﬂu-:_.ﬂ Lr LL} v.1) a; (. 45),- v,:;’.-.C‘.I: L C .2 3: a; , )1: ‘.’-1’1. 1 ‘v’ A .1 LE: taxi ., {”1753 d 1: C7 , n {J 1' J. UH“. ,
».‘2, .- m. f’ .3 "L L» ... . »Z ‘ /. _... m, J. .- ‘ ... :. .. , .L..- ... :~ . . In.
2 ‘1 J}: : w "(‘.‘ ,{3 u :r .3 LL». In? : -. $71336: ~17]. ‘.‘. 4..; ., ::.: .r v.13" 11.12.63
(\‘g, , .7 4:: {.3 .4. ,> An .. _. ., .‘:1._.,. . .. , .( , .. r- .. 4", W ‘ : . . ,. I. ‘ . '
AQC'EAUHI. b 3 , 111} 50.17. BU... 153 ...‘ 071.- .1..} \ _1 . f J.'.13.,_LC . 4..”. (3C; ,- . '2 1975." , 31.53 We
... 4.1.5.4. :.. ,. ..L; . 4 . . ,.,. . JW. , .'...:..-,_
3:3le :5 L‘. .' l: :39 ...K: ‘_'; H/ (2.1, ": ., :} Lu... E‘C '..". '2 g, ::i . ('3 ;JJ. 5.: .L .‘ . 310..
.cr :-.7..U.L135.;.., he 3 1 a : .. ~ ‘1be 2.3-2-1...“ 1:1... rum ,. a- s 3. ...-V110. :
."» ~. '11‘ .1. '1 .-~ ..'; ~ 4“ ; '.‘ A ‘. ' ,‘i ' 2'- vx :
M231... 1133‘ J Tv..0' .2.}:5}. [..‘ 13!”? in} '.x. 1'. .1: A. :1) a

 .
1
.
i
. -;- .' ” .:': ,HT, , 4.1”.) i M ”‘4'.@C¢ (1,52 57""‘5'8‘1
“'”‘ ""1"" “a cud-~11 +1543“? 'M‘w :rz“11.','w':(:1‘ (1H 32.4: er‘V «'_i‘i‘u; 1.11.1.3 (’OLHrul,u ,1 ...1 .1 9
34¢. .:_\.J.L fl}, nt.-‘7»: «'36.... J-. ,L..... 1.... , ,_l
3 [I
.",/?//3/'~/7/K»1C”/v v r 1 r. 5
. , —, . .., _ . ..,. 1p, ,1: '1" 1,“ ;. CT” {-.1 J . 'f ‘,.,“ ’
:-:.:::;='-.:"1,, S:;.::n.'3r:£:0;r1, 3” 1405A a,».;<1_4_02.=<1, mmmm (3,1 urrhm ..11 [1,; me
° " » 4* Ar . “__.: 'I ‘ - .
. 3 o - 1' . ,,: , 1 . . ’ ‘9 f) .3 ‘I'" ‘.. —L,‘ ..‘ A19 '1 g.) £3 ‘ 87C; ‘_(‘DLO \JULler‘thS
of 85:31.01 1.101111133103, 1011.16. m. 1111151133." m3 1.9.30.1. la, 1 .
3. .1 3. ... a. - _ _ ..; ‘E H. . \ﬁ .,_ 1 £7 . 7,.“, .’., .31 r:_; .,.. ’LL"? (.,‘, Chin’le
5.1-3 1.11:6,{31‘1137 ,iémnoezzurzu, 12.3,er .»::mmn 343 111,131,111- :9.th L 11 ,F m
"’ " "” '“’ "”1 “tr 1 “1"" '4’? 1'm“>81'1':'i;27 "51111375 431.15, {.'cmlx'i: =01:
31.101110. 4:013 .‘.:t3’3U..1.:3 J 113.3 1. T 33. ,_,. ,
' ‘ ' “i ' + 1‘11 MM "i “<1 1mm” and 11m? (“'1' "SW3 :1 dew-2111793121011
:'.,::..“,»'.;«1, 13.11: 13:13:11,; 1.01.01: 41mm, 1.41» 1- T , 1, . 3 . . _ _
- ~ - 3' ,_, ‘ . J3 , 1., :1.“ 1../3.
if: :T114 3 :15 53.21-01.11??? Ev; 111—13:. ...;011.«.u..0m.3

 . )>~
..
f, 4 , .._ H . ,‘
“cont 1,111.21” Vogm
’ .- w “w'x .,, .. ‘7 .L‘, ,.. . ‘1": “.1. ., 1'3, . "1'1 .‘ . . .- 0.:-
(301.1111u.1,11m..—.11 1.11 :‘.” 3.13.11. 1111:1131 1.:. 1.2.1111
”,1." ‘11 WAT" "Tm 1;
1! ‘0' 3“ L101 .Luiu‘ . if! ‘.I . a .
q ' (V ,.w» -~
LAX/WV 1/ WW: , [WAN - ‘
r1 .. 4.1 , . n... 1,: 4. *1 ,. H. - .,. .. _... -. r. m u. 4.1., «w .. 1, 4. ., '1
1.011135 m 113131611411...» ,, bale?) £011qu , am. uluvrﬁb 1.1.1»: 1.1.1.1117: 1.0 sent:
7”; \
A » ,
$2.5th
.1,. ,, . , - A: ,. J_'l,‘l.\ Q _ . , ,‘ [7“ ,.,.., - . ,.. 7,1 ..,, . «..L . t3 ,. .,_ 1
Quantum 01111-31," 1.111.111 1.1-«>11: , Owen, .1411 1.15011, sag-11 1.1.1.4. , 1.1111311111,
“:31. ...,..,v . .3 ,n ,. .11.. ..1_», .,. ... .1.. 7,. -., .. ”:»1 ‘.. .,.., . — : 1. . .,~..,'1 .,1. 432. ..
HULL f. 01:11 14,121.. 1:38.11 {1 L: u 5;)L1Ls'l'10ﬁ hilt? .,3 13.1.1.1. i 9 1.15342 43.13,); g] 3,. a .. -» 5.111.891, 1:13;?
43“,." , r... .' 0.1) ,, .1 .1., .,..“... . ., .,, . ._ ,«~ ,,... . .. .4 ,..}.(‘= .4. 1,.. .1 ..f; ,.,.-, 5 ,. ,. 1,., , .14.. .5 ,. .._ '.',
.4116: 2, .L 1.; Lu 131.11.113.01; {35.111113 Tram 131:2? «V1 1111'," £141.11J‘J; £1,115 1:1,: 1.1.11 v .1133 , (;be 119
. --.... 4-1, ._.1. 2.,. ..,,. .- _.‘) .. ...,.,...- ., e... -4..-1 T. .. ,.. . .,., 41.1,, . 7‘ .. , 4L4 - . ».»,1?
13:11.51: 1.111.). U 1.11 :0; .Ln. 131311111, 1.1%.: 11.11? 11.32:“: 1112-: mafia-2611 1.1.19. 3511111281 1. .11: r111»...
y. "- ‘ ' .. 1: “..~ » A. ' p. 41,,“ .,..... .z ., . . .. _'\ g. rung; - 1; ,,
lieguuiican 141.13.}..{5‘L 1J1: 11.113 1115 L: 1.141191.112111111131 13311318 2‘31.- /U‘.1 «511;. 1,121.101453 .
n ,, ._.1,“ 1",, .,. .. .,‘ ».. ‘1‘?- 1_.." -' ~~.,«~ . .v
0011.11.13? 1,.-1:110 1:33.11. ... r: 1113111113111111113 .

 M2. fur he says that $0 Summon said jury fram tha counties of Swan,
A I" .
‘ . ﬁl‘M/{ngV/g) 1, 7"] ‘
Scott, Harrison? anaﬁtw, ﬂoodford, Bouyujn or Granﬁ or any one
A
of said Countias, vauld be unfair tn dafeméanﬁx, aa Saiﬁ Counties
are largely Bemocratic, and $0 summon a jury from amy one of same
would not secure to him a fair and impartial jury, and woulﬁ noﬁ
give him aqua: protecticn under the law, and wwuld be a ﬁepwivaﬁion
ﬁf hi3 rights as secured by the 14th Amendmeni.

 \
Scott Cifcuit CQurt.
Commonwaalth 0f Keﬁtuaky Elaiﬂﬁiff
vs:- MOTION N00 3.
Caleb Bowerg Eefaai&nt
Comes ﬁne ﬁefenﬁ&nﬁv Caleb Powers, and cbjacts ta the

orﬂer 0f the Caurt direcﬁing the Sheriff ﬁe gummon the jury fram
the CWEF’ItL}? Sf _ , and. he. 3:3:rzaae-fiijh filers a muffied
copy of ﬁhe vsta of said Coamﬁy for bath ﬁﬁe Republican auﬁ Demo—
cratia ticketSin the laaﬁ Gubernaﬁorial race.

And ha alga files hagawith a like V0€3 in Raiﬁ raca fax the
"0:32" ,- m “JV"E‘R 53‘
¢\,LL_LOM}.H; KER CUMLJ '.LSQ»

 M2

5 Ami mews-3:3 the: Court“ t0 AMEN-oi the She riff anﬁ. his: deputiea to
summon the ‘tven'ire fr 01:1 one of Ezzzid, -:;=o"::.2ir€:i<=n3, as; "2.29 gag-3 'ﬁi"a,ar‘.r; by
reason of the poli‘aicm‘; complaxiori of Said’ (300.113.? of
same being; Largely Democraﬁic, he camwt obtain tlmrefmm a fair
ail-'3. impartial jury ﬁzz; {iffy his cage; '».rvhi'ie ﬁrm; aithar of {32:62 other
«30111111193 ragenﬁioned. he would be more likely to Obﬁain such jury.

 {xyxti. cizxniit;iieu3“t.
Commonwealth of ;entxchy ”iaiutiff
“3:31-— .:;3’Ii'fx,'.i:3‘i Ho. 9.
Caleb ”ouers Lefendent
Comes tnc defendrnt, Caleb fevers, swﬂ ohbwetg to the
order of the Gouxt directing the ﬁneriff to summon tie jury from
the llu.7_:e’2ti'7 of ,, rand me it! files a certified
copy a? tee vote of said ﬂounty for both the Republican sun Yeme—
cratic ticket in hue Last «uuernatorial race.
And he also Files serenith . like vote in gain race ”or the
follouin; awn counties:

 :Q 536 moveg tun Quart Eu dixect awe #595iff :55 big deyutiea to
summon the venire F on one of 5:14;: (mum; 14:34:14, Sm 532-44755 27:44: “i; by
rem-'40}: of 12:16: 13011431051 Conlpiazcion of 43:41:! 230113153;
4s; 4 e 591314;; largely .i‘emoczm‘bic, 4:43 2.5545515“; Ohm-Lira 6.41.5:reji’y‘om :: f if

: 94m": impartial jury to 133737 his 3:59, 4'11110 $2503. 4443: 71) 544.0 other
bounties mentioned. 210 wouui. be 445-156; ilk-434-737 “E10 0473:2111 553.04; 4 jury.

 . ~11; 4 4 ..--;.. _., :7
v. .:W‘.‘ ...4.
\- :12. - A 1. . .‘. * " ‘ 4 _ . ' '
'” ' ‘4” 1 »
...... _.....“ WWW. .
. . a.“ ~; 1 . ,.‘.‘
4.4.4 '2. , . .- .4
‘ ..2 '1‘: .._ - . ,2 7 . . -.‘ "_r." ,..... ...ﬂ . ‘.‘ , ’4!» . f1 .1 , V,.1,.,‘.1.‘. .'(U
k.=(.‘ I“ ”"‘:.” K- “"2 w} 4 r,‘ -‘- \4 , =4.“ .LL'? H . UH 631. x} 3 x. ‘.'-J I -1 '. ’ ~33) {I .‘7 ".31!“ H mm
.
n .4 ..,,. ..: .:. ._. ,. ..' ..'? '1 2. . ; .4 1'.. ...-.'. .. .‘. ._ ,.. ‘4 .2 . J, 1. ,1 A: ,. .
U. .3...’ {EC :.- 5.:.f 74133321 .. 54'. :24»? L2; 4.114.433» .144 41.8.4.1» {j a: JUNK, _.'.U. ;.=:..,.21.1 . J“.
vx-H‘J 4."? 44. 7'47; 2.41., . . $441.; '4'4; .4.-{4 24.24.30?) 1%,. ms; 1 44.2.. L- _;,U J ,4_,,_L 4 U 49:30:: .Ll
«4 .. .2 . 4 -. ‘. ‘4 2 ' ,4 55:, ., -4~: '14:- .. 4 . m2. ,4 r. 'm. ‘ 1':
14* 1-:.3R"-.3§.?SE}.J».';' .L‘izil c'..L "4_;.:'.';.!.J._!...L(_l<"3 (4.4. ab: 1".-' c' u ' ;crw ‘.«JWM, .. '... 4A..
‘ 1 7 ' N A i . ~-
’.‘ ',...: ,‘. ._ .‘.., ,... . ,. , ‘1 1 A .1 .5 .. '4 4.. ..‘A»; ‘ 1. .’ ,.. g_... ,1 .; :_. .1, ,2 .4.... 1,: ,
L' .3 “a .5 L153 . ;= ‘.{i‘lE'..i”.L_"’ 4;.3 23%: ..‘» “~J‘STEJ. 4.4.4.”? ,'.';ﬁ m.” 2.2 l z.» .‘.; .2... \: _;, ._ 1 ”.42).; ,1_ LI L (.... ».L
14:3.
._ _,.'AW: 7.. . * ‘\ ‘ 3 ,‘ '.' (.., .I, . _K.." ' 1. . 4‘"; - ._‘ .‘. _ '.-. ]... . >..~-’~-‘ V ”..,.,_ ',..‘.'.._' f, ‘..'.
...2-.:. «:4 , 2 4331.1.“ . ,x.) .Jx;=l.: :.in C -‘._:_2.4 7.1171. .2453 F. ;‘.)(.’.3.’.c¢ 4.4.1.: . .-}\» «91.44.43 L164...
. .
-, ”Hi 2“; ("1
L1. ‘A'" \.rA."
_-_-.,.~,........ .._... V ...W.,..,..,.W......W...W...WW,_

 '7s‘! .‘ "'n
“vi,” a 1 ' " ‘
. .. ..
If
u". - - . 3’ '-..W. a
.
,. .ML ..- . \. ..z . . -,. .J..: , .1 ,. '. .. ,. ...” .7. :3 . -:. .. ”.'. .:
«:3: has. 3.: .‘.“; UL. 2) .xUG’.‘ :-;.v.,.\=; 2 . as) 1.1.“...- £73.}. x. 3,5: ‘.MJLLL :..: L- ; : 1,.:
L ; ‘rr ‘x""~"“m"~:_u'l 4: .~«,.,_»_-._» 7' '. ‘ " ;.': r: ~. * " 4‘; ’3 -;:‘7"‘\‘ ':‘ ’- 3w" 2' .‘ \"5 ,"I «3.» x n. ."':r: '-"'
u“ (XV bug. m... -;_ ‘4. .1 .1., ..'.J Mu. . L- .'., - 1,.1. . . (.-. :.- r.» ..L é... .._:y‘» , m.,“. vL.-..., 4:: ,
MM {44/ VL/O/l/;ZW4_.
.x. ,. , ‘ . .. .. L ' : ‘~ “.5“: L q (2 ...: .-. L. — L: . _ J.
‘:L} m. '..) :1 :3 f3 136-0 ; ,5. . >3; $.72" , .:‘Hﬂi‘w , 3' :‘J-A'z '74.?!) 923/1“. L.
/1 / ,‘m .... ‘wan-w -
.I_.1">;.1 me’n- 1'” thy-311221.13.» 1. {1.7 (it) Wiwéit‘ﬁ each ‘zx‘vf‘w‘
"............_,._.,.L..MW.WW..W.-N....L L, s -- - ~ . -- -- , ~ ~ 3
.1 ’ 'i' .. «1»; r4“; T: n r-.. ,: ;- n-v. . . »L . 1T, , . . “ .T' . ~34 .« .L-
-J “.- 3 4.35.}. ‘.‘ an] ‘3'; (ji!,b§‘.‘.s.\.L\'r (ii 1 v w’.‘. ‘ I.» , ‘=\‘ l g ’ l ; ‘1‘ \'(.v.'L1,\‘ Cr . lR‘. ’.i .A.;J'yi “if;
.,.—T .,Lv' .. L" 1,. L .:. .. L ...: .. . ...- ... ,_.. , ...... L ; . .. .. .- ,. ' , ..,L _...0 . 1
.3. ﬁx , , :3.! E; u]. :92; 1:95. 6395 é-r 3. ;‘-.-.'e“;>f‘.v‘3 :2 w..Lf) 2.10221. 3.1. uh; O... E‘ .',.2‘138
LL. . ,, _}., 1% J.. I..: 4.1“.- ‘.I. , :1 I, M __I ..-' \ ' »J v ..'...» ‘..- J.J. L; {1’ E' J.J i; H ~“' I L. L. .'. (x .- « ‘
. .
~ I . z,
“A” 71/9“ MUM/'4‘)“, .
{5 mx ..'. I, ,...vv..- .' ,_. 1 ,1 L ,n . mm“: . 3., .. . .-... .. 1 '1 ., v. . .z .1
. (.:. Lv 11 . 3.114;; 1.1- . ;-,~:,.4_;//L.;;uh .J ‘J..-:. '-' ~52: .'. H: ! _:. 2. Liza up»? :_ 3.111. , . 5...}; A"! 11.1 ;-‘~-:..u. l.
‘ 3 7.»: -=,f-" “:7 L.‘.(Mwlrm (:.. ..; m S‘wpnch. «“uwx. n ,,ﬂ-i- ‘ - '31
. ”‘.I, ,..,.‘. ~.....Lu1', »..n. .,.V dud. ,4_-Lu . ._ 2. "91‘." e »"«.L1...Iul;,r :-
. . , .V- ;. L: ..! z ,. ./:= -.. ..; L 11.1 ,. . f . '..- .‘w. .. ' - . ‘ ’
I -. ' Ayah-.'- L- » 1v 2.9 . 3.2 ,. .:‘r‘.’ ‘~' .:.L: Li {rub-3 i :.L‘ :»th i .3 2.3:: 5+ .3 1 3.1-3
L ‘ -‘ we W' .~ r 4 ”a“, “a” . -] w" H: .,
, . .L u..v r 'x- .',-;,<. .L|.,,.:,' “ .1. my") , uni. {1.1. 1. .LI.-u 1 =1. ‘..: ‘3 w x" , ' '-. \JG...‘.-..-1.a. i1.) van ‘.I .L‘ - U .:.{Jﬁs ‘...‘f. 3.': .3 U“
.—,~...,L : 'g y. +13» _, '«w ,. ,. ,v .3 (4, .: ,- '7 :2 ~ ' ‘ ;. t» ,-, .. . r.
-. .L L, ' .'. Lav .L..» U} ..